Assessing Sentencing Disparities under the New Criminal Code: A Critical Analysis of Judicial Discretion and Sentencing Considerations

Authors

  • Kif Aminanto Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Kepolisian, Jakarta, Indonesia
  • Meddif Wisudawan Bima Sakti Kusnan Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Kepolisian, Jakarta, Indonesia
  • Denys Illiashchuk Institute of Law and Security, Odessa State University of Internal Affairs, Odessa, Ukraine

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.66325/68e9tt12

Keywords:

AI Analytics, Judicial Discretion, Judicial Pardon, New Criminal Code, Sentencing Disparity.

Abstract

Indonesia’s criminal law reform raises a central question of sentencing consistency: how can courts justify different outcomes while preserving individualised justice? This study assesses the potential for sentencing disparities during the transition to the new criminal law framework, focusing on judicial discretion and the considerations informing sentencing decisions. Using a qualitative doctrinal method, it examines Law No. 1 of 2023, Law No. 20 of 2025, Supreme Court Circular Letter No. 1 of 2026, and the sector-specific framework under Supreme Court Regulation No. 1 of 2020. A limited comparison with Dutch sentencing orientation points and sentencing guidance in England and Wales complements statutory and conceptual interpretation. No independently documented corpus of judicial decisions is analysed; therefore, the findings concern the normative framework rather than measured patterns of judicial outcomes. The analysis finds that identifying relevant sentencing factors is distinct from explaining their influence on the sentence imposed. A judicial pardon also requires separate justification when punishment or measures are withheld after guilt has been established. Existing operational guidance does not provide a comprehensive method for selecting comparable cases or explaining departures across otherwise factually similar cases. Accordingly, the study proposes a guided discretionary matrix connecting legal applicability, case-specific facts, statutory considerations, comparator selection, and reasons for the final disposition. The matrix structures judicial reasoning and assesses the comparability of reasons without demanding identical sentences or assigning unsupported numerical weights. The study contributes a conceptual framework for evaluating sentencing consistency during legal transition in comparable Indonesian criminal cases. AI-assisted retrieval is identified only as a possible future research aid; neither the matrix nor any algorithm has been empirically tested, and no reduction in sentencing disparity is claimed.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

  • Meddif Wisudawan Bima Sakti Kusnan, Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Kepolisian, Jakarta, Indonesia

    Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Kepolisian, Jakarta, Indonesia

References

Ali, Mahrus, Hamad F Al-Fahad, and Wasikh Maulana. “Philosophical Foundation, Application, and Controversies of Judicial Pardon in Islamic Criminal Law, Indonesian Penal Code, and the Criminal Justice System of Kuwait.” De Jure: Jurnal Hukum Dan Syar’iah 17, no. 2 (2025): 624–648.

Amiati, Mia, Taufik Rachman, and R B Muhammad Zainal Abidin. “Urgency of Falsum in Indonesian Criminal Justice System as Basis for Revision; An Islamic Perspective.” AL-IHKAM: Jurnal Hukum & Pranata Sosial 19, no. 2 (2024): 303–328.

Anwar, A. Pemaafan Hakim (Rechterlijk Pardon) Dalam KUHP Nasional Konstruksi Norma Dan Implikasi Bagi Sistem Pemidanaan. Indonesia Emas Group, 2026.

Ardiansyah, Irfan. Disparitas Pemidanaan Dalam Perkara Tindak Pidana Korupsi (Penyebab Dan Penanggulangannya). Hawa dan AHWA, 2017.

Bego, Karolus Charlaes, Christian Ade Wijaya, Yanto Irianto, and Halisma Amili. “Paradigma Baru Hukum Pidana Nasional: Analisis Normatif Terhadap Undang-Undang Nomor 1 Tahun 2023 Tentang Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Pidana: New Paradigm of National Criminal Law: Normative Analysis of Law Number 1 of 2023 Concerning the Criminal Code.” Jurnal Kolaboratif Sains, 2025, 7482–7490.

Budiyono, Wahid. “Pengaruh Teori Positivisme Hukum Terhadap Sistem Peradilan Pidana Di Indonesia.” In Prosiding Seminar Nasional Pendidikan, Bahasa, Sastra, Seni, Dan Budaya, 3:369–86, 2024.

Efendi, Jonaedi. “Metode Penelitian Hukum Normatif Dan Empiris,” 2018.

Effendi, Prihatin, Dwi Wachidiyah Ningsih, Nasichin Nasichin, and Yati Vitria. “Reformasi Hukum Pidana Indonesia.” Takaza Innovatix Labs, 2024.

Elmarianti, Elmarianti, and Nur Insani Aulia. “Pergeseran Paradigma Pemidanaan Indonesia: Implikasi Normatif Dan Tantangan Implementasi Keadilan Restoratif Dalam KUHP Nasional 2026.” Al-Mizan (e-Journal) 21, no. 2 (2025): 353–374.

Harsya, Rabith Madah Khulaili, Abdul Fatakh, and Umdah Aulia Rohmah. “Penetapan Sanksi Pidana Dan Tindakan Sebagai Sistem Pemidanaan Di Indonesia.” YUSTISIA MERDEKA: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum 8, no. 2 (2022): 57–63.

Henry, Encep, and Andhi Wibowo. “Disparitas Putusan Hakim Dalam Menjatuhkan Pidana Pada Tindak Pidana Narkotika.” Unes Journal of Swara Justisia 2, no. 1 (2018): 22–33.

Herista, Annisa Dian Permata, and Aristo Evandy A Barlian. “Rechterlijk Pardon Dalam Kebijakan Dan Penerapan Pidana Indonesia.” Pranata Hukum 15, no. 2 (2020): 132–142.

Irfani, Arsyaddefa Muhammad Fitra, and Abdul Fattaah. “Inconsistency of Judicial Verdicts in Standardising the Threshold of Noodweer Exces: A Review of Criminal Law and Islamic Law.” Asy-Syari’ah: Jurnal Hukum Islam 12, no. 1 (2026): 31–45.

Kristiawanto, S H I. Memahami Penelitian Hukum Normatif. Prenada Media, 2022.

Kurniati, Y., & Julianasari, W. “Precarious Work and Legal Protection: Insights into the Implementation of Labor Standards.” Khazanah Hukum 8, no. 1 (2026): 57–70.

Latifah, Marfuatul, and Prianter Jaya Hairi. “Pengaturan Pedoman Pemidanaan KUHP Baru Dan Implikasinya Pada Putusan Hakim.” Negara Hukum: Membangun Hukum Untuk Keadilan Dan Kesejahteraan 15, no. 2 (2025).

Nirmalasari, C. Q., & Maskur, M. A. “Penerapan Judicial Pardon Di Belanda Dan Indonesia: Analisis Komparatif Terhadap Rechtelijk Pardon Pada KUHP Baru Di Indonesia.” Legalite: Jurnal Perundang Undangan Dan Hukum Pidana Islam 11, no. 1 (2026): 116–136.

Nissa, K., Siswanto, H., Fardiansyah, A. I., Dewi, E., Ridlwan, Z., & Illiashchuk, D. “Reformulating Rechterlijk Pardon in the Criminal Procedure Code: A Comparative Study with the Dutch Criminal Justice System.” Nusantara: Journal of Law Studies 5, no. 2 (2026): 1486–1506.

Nissa, Khaoeirun, Heni Siswanto, Ahmad Irzal Fardiansyah, Erna Dewi, Zulkarnain Ridlwan, and Denys Illiashchuk. “Reformulating Rechterlijk Pardon in the Criminal Procedure Code: A Comparative Study with the Dutch Criminal Justice System.” Nusantara: Journal of Law Studies 5, no. 2 (2026): 1486–1506.

Pengadlan Negeri Negara. Surat Edaran Mahkamah Agung Nomor 1 Tahun 2026 tentang Pedoman Implementasi KUHP 2023 Dan KUHAP 2025 (2026).

Pratama, M Ilham Wira. “Penerapan Pasal 54 Ayat (1) KUHP Oleh Hakim Dalam Menjatuhkan Putusan Pemidanaan.” Indonesian Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (IJCLC) 5, no. 3 (2024).

Pratama, M Ilham Wira, and Donis Daviska. “Penerapan Pedoman Pemidanaan Bagi Hakim Sebelum Diundangkannya KUHP Baru.” Jurnal Fakta Hukum 4, no. 1 (2025): 13–20.

Rasiwan, I. Sistem Peradilan Pidana Menurut KUHP Baru: Mengurai Paradigma Dan Asas Keseimbangan. AMU Press, 2026.

Razif, Muhammad. “Larangan Kohabitasi Dalam UU No. 1 Tahun 2023: Suatu Penerapan Sadd Dzariah.” Al-’Adalah: Jurnal Syariah Dan Hukum Islam 8, no. 2 (2023): 212–224.

Riady, Roy, Febrian Febrian, Nashriana Nashriana, and M Yusuf. “Reformulating the Reversal of the Burden of Proof in Corruption Cases: Integrating Positive Law and Islamic Legal Principles.” Nurani: Jurnal Kajian Syari’ah Dan Masyarakat 25, no. 2 (2025): 514–528.

Rohayu, Rina. “Analisis Disparitas Pemidanaan Terhadap Penyuapan Dalam Tindak Pidana Korupsi.” Private Law 5, no. 2 (2025): 634–650.

Sanna, Andi Annisyah Tenri. “Tantangan Dan Peluang: Paradigma Pemidanaan Mengenai Restorative Justice Sebagai Rechterlijke Pardon Dalam KUHP Nasional.” Jurnal Interpretasi Hukum 6, no. 1 (2025): 61–76.

Soekanto, Soerjono. “Penelitian Hukum Normatif: Suatu Tinjauan Singkat,” 2007.

Sonafist, Y., Nurjanah, N., & Abouabaid, W. “Contested Puberty: Judicial Discretion, Moral Regulation, and the Persistence of Child Marriage in Indonesia,” n.d.

Suparno, E. W., Hadianto, A., & Hutasoit, I. “Disparitas Pemidanaan Korupsi Dalam Perspektif Kepastian Hukum Dan Keadilan Publik.” Jurnal USM Law Review 9, no. 1 (2026): 341–360.

Tarnama, E. M., & Prasetyo, B. “Implications of Disparities in District Court and Supreme Court Decisions in Realizing Justice: Implikasi Disparitas Putusan Pengadilan Negeri Dan Mahkamah Agung Dalam Mewujudkan Keadilan.” Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review 21, no. 1 (2026): 10–21.

Tenrilawa, Dian Furqani, Achmad Ruslan, Aminuddin Ilmar, Marten Arie, and Lily Bauw. “Re-Bounding Emergency Lawmaking in Indonesia: Constitutional Design, Parliamentary Oversight, Islamic Law Perspectives, and Accountability after COVID-19.” Jurnal Ilmiah Mizani: Wacana Hukum, Ekonomi Dan Keagamaan 13, no. 1 (2026): 384–405.

Wibowo, I. A. Pembaruan KUHP Dan KUHAP Sebagai Rekonstruksi Sistem Hukum Di Indonesia, 2026.

Widiartana, Gregorius, and Sajjad Hussain. “Judicial Pardon in Contemporary Criminal Verdicts: Balancing Justice, Legal Certainty, and the Utility of Law.” Nusantara: Journal of Law Studies 4, no. 01 (2025): 1–11.

Yantory, R., & Suwardi, S. “Eksistensi Tindak Pidana Khusus Dalam Sistem Hukum Pidana Nasional Pasca-Pengesahan KUHP Baru.” Yantory, R., & Suwardi, S. 4, no. 3 (2026): 10341–1056.

Yarus, Muhammad Hazwi, and Zainudin Hasan. “Konsep Rechterlijk Pardon Dan Faktor-Faktor Yang Mempengaruhi Penerapannya Di Indonesia.” Jurnal Ilmiah Penelitian Mahasiswa 3, no. 4 (2025): 191–196.

Zilvia, Rahmi, and Haryadi Haryadi. “Disparitas Pidana Terhadap Pelaku Kasus Tindak Pidana Penganiayaan.” PAMPAS: Journal of Criminal Law 1, no. 1 (2020): 96–109.

Published

2026-11-20

How to Cite

Assessing Sentencing Disparities under the New Criminal Code: A Critical Analysis of Judicial Discretion and Sentencing Considerations. (2026). Nusantara: Journal of Law Studies, 6(1). https://doi.org/10.66325/68e9tt12

Similar Articles

11-20 of 66

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.

Most read articles by the same author(s)